Is the Banning of Importation of Second-Hand Clothes and Shoes a Panacea to Industrialization in East Africa?

Authors

  • Kitojo Kagome Wetengere

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.61538/ajer.v6i1.413

Abstract

The objective of this study was to investigate if the banning of importation of second-hand clothes and shoes is a panacea to industrialization in East Africa. Qualitative and quantitative secondary data were employed to validate the research objectives. The study found that most people used second-hand clothes and shoes bacause they were cheaper, good quality and fashionable. Likewise, the trade of second-hand clothes and shoes created employment, generated revenue and filled the gap during shortage. Nevertheless, the second-hand clothes and shoes trade contributed to the collapse and hamper the current initiative to revive the textiles and leather industries. Similarly, the trade has been associated with some skin diseases, had negative impact on self-esteem of the consumers and conflicted with some African values and traditions. Besides, there were some socio-economic and technical factors, influx of clothes and shoes from Asia as well as un-competitive local environment which contributed to the collapse of the former industries. In view of the above, the following were recommended: First, the phase-out of second-hand clothes and shoes should be gradual and implemented over a longer period of time (5-10 years) to lessen the impact of the ban on the lives of the consumers and traders. Second, the governments should put in place effective policies to control unfair competition of Asian products. Finally, the governments should rectify all factors that led to the collapse of the former industries and put in place a conducive business and investment environment necessary for the growth of the new industries.

Author Biography

Kitojo Kagome Wetengere

Centre for Foreign Relations (CFR), P. O Box 2824, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania

References

Bazzi, K., (2012). Review of the Socio-Economical Effects of Second Hand Clothing Smuggle to Iran (With the Comparative Approach between Zabol and Orumieh City in the East and West of the Country). J. Basic. Appl. Sci. Res., 2(3)2530-2540, 2012.

Bee, F. K., (2016). Mobilizing Co-operatives for a Higher Regional Development Impact. A presentation prepared for the First East African Co-operative Conference: organized at the Intercontinental Hotel, Nairobi Kenya from 29th February to 2nd March, 2016. http://www.industrialization.go.ke/images/downloads/feacc-materials/mobilizing-co-operativesfor-a-higher-regional-development-impact.pdf (Retrieved on 5th September, 2017).

Bradley, A., (2013). Second-Hand Clothing Undermines Africa’s Economy. http://blog.acton.org/archives/53203-second-hand-clothing-undermines-africaseconomy.html (Retrieved on 7th December, 2017).

Brooks, A., and Simon, D., (2012). Unraveling the Relationships between Used-Clothing Imports and the Decline of African Clothing Industries. Development and Change: 1-26. DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-7660.2012.01797.

Brooks, A., (2016). East Africa's ban on second-hand clothes won't save its own industry. https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/2016/may/04/east-africa-kenya-bansecond-hand-clothing-imports-west (Retrieved on 5th October, 2017).

Calabrese, L., (2016). Banning used clothes imports into East Africa will not help its manufacturing sector. https://www.odi.org/comment/10360-ban-used-clothes-importseast-africa-manufacturing-trade (Retrieved on 20th September, 2017).

CBC news, (2012). Clothing donation bins spark turf war on Ontario. Much of the money does not go to charity. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/clothing-donation-bins-spark-turfwar-in-ontario-1.1246132 (Retrieved on 2nd December, 2017).

Chand, S., (2016). Benefits of International Trade Export Management. http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/trade-2/8-benefits-of-international-trade-exportmanagement/5914/ (Retrieved on 5th October, 2017).

Chipambwa, W., Sithole, L., and Chisosa, D. L., (2016): Consumer perceptions towards second-hand undergarments in Zimbabwe: a case of Harare urban dwellers, International

Journal of Fashion Design, Technology and Education, DOI:

1080/17543266.2016.1151555.

East African Community (EAC) Secretariat, (2017). The Draft EAC Strategy/Action Plan for the Phase-Out Importation of Second-Hand Clothes/Shoes Within the Period 2017-2019.

Glorias, B., (2017). Do African Nations Want Your Second-Hand Clothes? Yes and No Is your donation doing more harm than good? https://www.alternet.org/world/do-africannations-want-your-second-hand-clothes-yes-and-no (Retrieved on 15th November, 2017).

Goldberg, E., (2016). These African Countries Don’t Want Your Used Clothing Anymore. Such imports have devastated the local clothing industries and led the region to rely far too heavily on the West. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/these-africancountries-dont-want-your-used-clothing-anymore_us_57cf19bce4b06a74c9f10dd6 (Retrieved on 20th October, 2017).

Gumede, W., (2017). 'Strict AGOA rules put African policies and trade on the line' - Columnist. https://agoa.info/news/article/15265-strict-agoa-rules-put-african-policiesand-trade-on-the-line-columnist.html (Retrieved on 16th October, 2017).

Hansen, K. T., (2014). The Second-hand Clothing Market in Africa and its Influence on Local Fashions. DRESSTUDY, Vol.64, 2014.

Kabanda, E., (2016). My Dress, My Choice: Banning used clothes is not economics, its idiocy. http://www.theeastafrican.co.ke/oped/comment/Banning-used-clothes-is-not-economicsit-is-idiocy-/434750-3388404-fc8qaoz/index.html (Retrieved on 12th October, 2017).

Katende-Magezi, E., (2017). “The Impact of Second Hand Clothes and Shoes in East Africaâ€.3Geneva. CUTS International, Geneva.http://www.cuts-geneva.org/pdf/PACT2STUDY-The_Impact_of_Second_Hand_Clothes_and_Shoes_in_East_Africa.pdf (Retrieved on 29th September, 2017).

Kelly, K., (2017). Revisit ban on Second-hand clothes, EAC states urged. The CITIZEN, Monday, 14th August, 2017.

Kho, N. D., (2011). Used clothing: Donate or dump? http://www.sfgate.com/green/article/Used-clothing-Donate-or-dump-2334866.php (Retrieved on 15th October, 2017).

Kinabo, O. D., (2004). The Textile Industry and the Mitumba Market in Tanzania. A Paper Presented to the Tanzania-Network.de Conference on textile market and Textile Industry in Rural and Urban areas in Tanzania on 23rd October 2004 in Potsdam-Germany. http://www.tanzaniagateway.org/docs/Textile_Industry_and_the_Mitumba_Market_in_T anzania.pdf (Retrieved on 10th October, 2017).

Kiruki, A., (2016). East Africa govts must employ industry-friendly policies to revamp textile sector. http://www.theeastafrican.co.ke/rwanda/Opinion/East-Africa-must-employindustry-friendly-policies-in-textile/1433246-3363110-t2c31uz/index.html (Retrieved on 13th October, 2017).

Kubania, J., (2015). How second-hand clothing donations are creating a dilemma for Kenya. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/06/second-hand-clothing-donations-kenya (Retrieved on 11th November, 2017).

Mashindano, O. J., (2017). Fursa na Changamoto Katika Uchumi wa Viwanda Kwa Maendeleo ya Jamii. Mada iliyowasilishwa katika Kongamano Maalumu la Maazimisho ya Kumbukizi ya Mwalimu Julius K. Nyerere Chuo cha Kumbukumbu ya Mwalimu Nyerere Tarehe 11 Oktoba 2017.

Milner, G., (2014). Don’t be clothes-minded: understanding the impact of donated clothes. Http://Www.Whydev.Org/Dont-Be-Clothes-Minded-Understanding-The-Impact-OfDonated-Clothes/ (Retrieved On 15th October, 2017).

Moses, K. C., (2016). A Study on the Performance of Textile Sector in Tanzania-Challenges and ways Forward.© International Academic Research Journal of Business and Management Vol. no.4 issue no 5, February 2016, Page No. 1-14 ISSN No: 2227-1287 (Print).

Msambichaka L. A., Mduma J. K., Selejio O., and Mashindano O. J., (2015). In Msambichaka L. A., Mduma J. K., Selejio O. & Mashindano O. J. (eds). How can Tanzania Move from Poverty to Prosperity. Dar es Salaam, Dar es Salaam University Press, pp 43 - 82.

Mudida, R., (2009). Modern Economics. Second Edition. Focus Publication, Nairobi Kenya. PP. 525.

Mussa, U. A., (2014). Industrial Development and Its Role in Combating Unemployment in Tanzania: History, Current Situation and Future Prospects. A Paper Presented at the VET Forum, 10-11 November, 2014, Arusha. http://www.veta.go.tz/assets/uploads/d40f9VET-FORUM-PAPER-Dr--Uledi.pdf (Retrieved on 10th October, 2017).

Mwai, C., (2017). Trade experts fault US over AGOA review. https://agoa.info/news/article/15170-trade-experts-fault-us-over-agoa-review.html (Retrieved on 20th October, 2017).

New Indian Express - NIE (2016). Northeast India, a dumping ground for used Korean Clothes?

https://thenortheasttoday.com/northeast-india-a-dumping-ground-for-used-korean-clothes/ (Retrieved on 16th October, 2017).

Simbakalia, J. I., (2015). In Msambichaka L. A., Mduma J. K., Selejio O., and Mashindano O. J. (Eds). How can Tanzania Move from Poverty to Prosperity. Dar es Salaam, Dar es Salaam University Press, pp. 43 - 82.

Tamura, K. F., (2017). For Dignity and Development, East Africa Curbs Used Clothes Imports. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/12/world/africa/east-africa-rwanda-usedclothing.html (Retrieved on 7th December, 2017).

Todaro, M., P., (1977). Economic for a Developing World. Longman Group Limited, London, UK. Pp. 444.

United Republic of Tanzania - URT (2011). Country report on Millennium Development Goals 2010. Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Pp. 66.

World Bank (2016); Doing Business. Economic Ranking. http://www.doingbusiness.org/rankings (Retrieved on 22nd September, 2017).

World Economic Forum - WEF (2012; 2014; 2016; 2017). The Global Competitive Report:

-2012; 2013-2014; 2015-2016; 2017-2018. http://www3.weforum.org/docs/GCR2017-

/05FullReport/TheGlobalCompetitivenessReport2017%E2%80%932018.pdf (Retrieved on 29th December, 2017).

Downloads