What does it take to be heard in managing marine protected areas? Insights from Tanzania coastal communities
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61538/ajer.v4i1.462Abstract
This paper explores the debate on participatory approach by presenting evidence from the local communities practices living within the marine protected area in Tanzania (Mnazi Bay RuvumaEstuary Marine Park). Five out of fifteen villages that exist in Mnazi Bay Marine Park were selected for this study after consultation with the park authority. Stratified sampling of villages was conducted based on the location from the Indian Ocean: three villages located close to the sea (sea front villages) and two villages located far from the sea (inland villages). Both quantitative and qualitative data were collected using semi-structured questionnaires, focus group discussions, participant observation and interviews. The findings are presented using the local community narratives on livelihoods strategies and participation in decision-making processes to highlight the challenges of a participatory conservation approach in marine resources management within MPAs and also using regression analysis to explain the factors determining their participation. A Logit regression model is run. Results show that participatory approach in MPAs is a challenging phenomenon due to existence of multifaceted layers in marine resources management and use. These layers exist in terms of power struggle to manage resources and extract benefits associated with marine resources between state and local communities. This power struggle tends to undermine the ability of local communities to use and manage marine resources, threatening the attainment of the main objective of establishing the MPAs that’s improving the livelihood of the adjacent communities and improving the resources.References
Banerjee, A. V. and Duflo, E. (2007) “The economic lives of the poor,†Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 21(1): 141-67.
Béné, C., Belal, E., Baba Malloun, O., Ovie, s., Raji, A., Malasha, I., and Njaya, F., (2009)
“Power Struggle, Dispute and Alliance Over Local Resources: Analyzing ‘Democratic’
Decentralization of Natural Resources through the Lenses of Africa Inland Fisheries†World Development. Vol. 37 (12): 1935-1950
Berkes, F. (2004). Rethinking Community Based Conservation. Conservation Biology. Vol.
(3): 621–630
Fabricius, C. (2004) “The Fundamentals of Community Based Natural Resource Management,†In Fabricius, C. and Koch, E. (Eds.) with Magome, H. and Turner, S. (2004). Rights, Resources and Rural Development: Community Based Natural Resource Management in Southern Africa. EarthScan, London UK.
Gawler, M. and Muhando, C. (2004). Development of Mnazi Bay-Ruvuma Estuary Marine Park Mid-term Evaluation. UNDP/GEF Project– United Republic of Tanzania (URT).
Available online at cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/mnazi_bay_mid_term_review_abst.pdf. Accessed on 20 January 2011
Hara, M. (2004) “Beach village committees as a vehicle for community participation: Lake Malombe/Upper Shire River participatory programme,†In Fabricius, C. and Koch,
E. (Eds.) with Magome, H. and Turner, S. (2004). Rights, Resources and
Rural Development: Community Based Natural Resource Management in Southern Africa. EarthScan, London UK.
Leach, M, Mearns, R. and Scoones, I. (1999) ‘Environmental Entitlements: Dynamics and
Institutions in Community-Based Natural Resource Management’, World Development 27 (2): 223-247
Magome, H. and Fabricus, C. (2004). “Reconciling biodiversity conservation with rural development: the holy grail of CBNRM?†In Fabricius, C. and Koch, E. (Eds.) with Magome, H. and Turner, S. (2004). Rights, Resources and Rural Development: Community Based Natural Resource Management in Southern Africa. EarthScan, London UK
Malleret, D. (2004) A Socio-economic Baseline Assessment of the Mnazi Bay Ruvuma Estuary Marine Park (IUCN EARO - Nairobi) 126pp.
Malleret, D. and Simbua, J. (2005) The Occupational Structure of the Mnazi Bay - Ruvuma Estuary Marine Park Communities, (IUCN EARO) 42pp.
Mascia, M. B., and Claus, A. C. (2009) “A property rights approach to understanding human displacement from protected areas: the case of marine protected areas,†Conservation Biology. Vol.23: 16–23.
Mascia, M.B. Claus, A.C. and Naidoo, R. (2010) “Impacts of Marine Protected Areas on Communities,†Conservation Biology, Vol.24: 1424-1425
Muhando, C.A., Mndeme, Y.E, and Kamukuru, A.T. (1998) Mnazi Bay-Ruvuma Estuary proposed marine park: Environmental Assessment Report. Prepared for IUCN and World Bank. 29pp.
Mwaipopo, R. N. (2008) The Social Dimensions of Marine Protected Areas: a Case Study of the Mafia Island Marine Park in Tanzania. SAMUDRA Monograph. Chennai, India: International Collective in Support of Fishworkers (ICSF).
Nelson, Fred. (2010) “Introduction: The politics of Natural resource governance in Africa,†In community rights, conservation and contested land: the politics of natural resource governance in Africa. Nelson, F (ed.). 3-31. Earth scan. Washington D.C
Nelson, F. and Agrawal, A. (2008). “ Patronage or Participation? Community based Natural Resource Management Reform in Sub Saharan Africa,†Development and Change. Vol. 39 (4): 557-585
Peng, C.J., Lee, K.L. and Ingersoll, G.M. (2002). “An Introduction to Logistic Regression Analysis and Reporting,†The Journal of Educational Research. Vol. 96 (1): 3-14
Ribot, J.C., Chhatre, A., and Lankina, T. (2008) Introduction: Institutional choice and recognition in the formation and consolidation of local democracy. Conservation and Society. 6(1): 1-11
Ritchie, J., Lewis, J., & Elam, G. (2003) “Designing and selecting samples,†In J. Ritchie & J. Lewis (Eds.), Qualitative research practice (pp. 77-108). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Sanchirico, J.N., Cochran, K.A. and Emerson, P.M. (2002) Marine Protected Areas: Economic and Social Implications. Discussion Paper 02–26 Resources for the Future.
p
Shackleton, S., Campbell, B. Wollenberg, E. and Edmunds, D. (2002). Devolution and
Community Based Natural Resource Management: Creating Space for Local
People to Participate and Benefit? Natural Resource Perspectives. Number
Schroeder, R. A. (1997) “ ‘Re-claiming’ land in the Gambia: Gendered Property Rights and
Environmental Intervention.†Annals of the Association of American Geographers 87 (3): 487-508.
Silva, P. (2006) “Exploring the Linkages Between Poverty, Marine Protected Area
Management, and the use of Destructive Fishing Gear in Tanzania,†World Bank Policy
Research Working Paper No. 3831
Songorwa, A. N. (1999). “Community Based Wildlife Management (CWM) in Tanzania: Are the Communities Interested?†World Development. 27(12): 2061-2079
Stevens, J. (2002) Applied Multivariate Statistics for the Social Sciences. Hillsdale, New Jersey:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates; 4th Edition
URT (United Republic of Tanzania). (1998) Mtwara region socio-economic profile. The Planning Commission and Mtwara Regional Commissioner’s Office. Available online at www.tzonline.org/pdf/Mtwara.pdf. Accessed online on October 30th 2010
URT (United Republic of Tanzania).(2005) Ministry of Natural Resources and Management. General Management Plan-Mnazi Bay Ruvuma Estuary Marine Park. 72 pp.
Walley, C. (2004) Rough Waters: Nature and Development in an African Marine Park. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press
Walpole, M and Wilder, L. (2008) “Disentangling the links between conservation and poverty reduction in practice†Fauna & Flora International, Oryx, Vol. 42(4): 539–
Wilson , D.C.K., Ahmed, M., Delaney, A., Donda, S., Kapasa, C.K., Malasha, I., Muyangali, K., Njaya, F., Olesen, T., Poiosse, E.,and J. Raakjær (2009) Power and Politics in Fisheries Co-Management Programmes in Southern Africa. Innovative Fisheries Management Publication No. 24.
World Bank, (2005). Blueprint 2050: Sustaining the Marine Environment in Mainland Tanzania and Zanzibar,. Ed. Jack Ruitenbeek, Indurmathie Hewawasam and Magnus Ngoile. New York: World Bank, 2005.
