Influencing public policy in Tanzania: Trials and tribulations of the Tanzania Horticultural Association
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61538/pajbm.v2i1.387Abstract
Interest groups aim to influence public policy and, therefore, interest groups representing business advocate improvements to the business enabling environment. Researchers claim that it is difficult to assess the extent to which interest groups influence public policy. Most research in this area focuses on the US and EU and little explores the factors that may determine whether business membership organisations (BMOs) are likely to be successful. This paper addresses those gaps. It explores the attempts by a BMO in Tanzania, the Tanzania Horticultural Association, to influence reform of public policy. It offers evidence that the association was successful, though mostly on issues that might be regarded as technical rather than contentious or political. The paper reviews the factors that have contributed to its success, which include providing good evidence, preparing a persuasive argument, using champions amongst public officials and engaging in dialogue, without confrontation, across government and concludes that this approach makes a difference in whether BMOs are successful.References
Baumgartner, F.R. and Mahoney, C. (2008), The two faces of framing: individual level framing and collective issue definition in the European Union, European Union Politics, 9 (3): 435-449.
Baumgartner, F.R., Berry, J.M., Hojnacki, M. et al (2009), Lobbying and policy change: who wins, who loses and why, University of Chicago Press, Chicago. 341pp.
Berry, J.M. (1997), The Interest Group Society, 3 ed, LongmanNew York
Bettcher, K.E. (2011), Making the most of public-private dialogue: an advocacy approach, Centre for International Private Enterprise: Washington, DC
Beyers, J. and Braun, C. (2014), Ties that count: explaining interest group access to policymakers, Journal of Public Policy, 34 (1): 93-121.
Bouwen, P. (2002), Corporate lobbying in the European Union: the logic of access, Journal of European Public Policy, 9 (3): 365-390.
Braun, C. (2012), The captive or the broker? Explaining public agency-interest group interactions, Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration and Institutions, 25 (2): 291-314.
Buguzi, S (2017), Tanzania states why it opted out of Open Government Partnership, The Citizen, 30 Sep [http://iga.fyi/GoTogp1], Site visited 17 Oct 2017
Citizen, (2016), TAHA plans to double exports in three years, 29 Jan,
[http://iga.fyi/tahap60b7], Site visited 10 October 2016)
Cooksey, B. (2011), The investment and business environment for export horticulture in northern Tanzania, background note
Cooksey, B. and Kelsall, T. (2011), The political economy of the investment climate in Tanzania, Overseas Development Institute for the Africa Power and Politics Programme London. 98pp.
Dür, A. (2008), Interest groups in the European Union: how powerful are they? West European Politics, 31 (6): 1212-1230.
Dür, A. and De Bièvre, D. (2007), The question of interest group influence, Journal of Public Policy, 27 (1): 1-12.
Dür, A. and Mateo, G. (2012), Who lobbies the European Union? National interest groups in a multilevel polity, Journal of European Public Policy, 19 (7): 969-987.
Eising, R. (2007), The access of business interests to EU institutions: towards elite pluralism, Journal of European Public Policy, 14 (3): 384-403.
Entman, R.M. (1993), Framing: toward clarification of a fractured paradigm, Journal of Communications, 43 (4): 51-58.
George, A.L. and Bennett, A. (2005), Case studies and theory development in the social sciences, MIT Press: Cambridge, Mass. 331pp.
Grossman, M. (2012), Interest group influence on US policy change: an assessment based on policy history, Interest Groups & Advocacy, 1 (2): 171-192.
Ihucha, A. (2015a), Making a name in horticulture, The Citizen, 15 Jan,
[http://iga.fyi/makinf277], Site visited 10 October 2016
Ihucha, A. (2015b), Prize takes boss of horticulture association to greater heights, The Citizen, 19 Mar, [http://iga.fyi/prizef3c5], Site visited 10 October 2016)
ILO, (2007), The promotion of sustainable enterprises, International Labour ConferenceGeneva, 96th session
Jones, N. and Villar, E. (2008), Situating children in international development policy:
challenges involved in successful policy influencing, Evidence & Policy: A Journal of Research Debate and Practice, 4 (1): 31-51.
Keck, M.E. and Sikkink, K. (1998), Activists across borders: advocacy networks in international politics, Cornell University Press: Ithaca. 242pp.
Kelsall, T. (2013), Business, politics, and the state in Africa: challenging the orthodoxies on growth and transformation, Zed BooksLondon. 190pp.
Kimball, D.C., Baumgartner, F.R., Berry, J.M. et al (2012), Who cares about the lobbying agenda? Interest Groups & Advocacy, 1 (5): 5-25.
Klüver, H. (2012), Informational lobbying in the European Union: the effect of organisational characteristics, West European Politics, 35 (3): 491-510.
Klüver, H., Mahoney, C. and Opper, M. (2015), Framing in context: how interest groups employ framing to lobby the European Commission, Journal of European Public Policy, 22 (4): 481-498.
Knaggård, A. (2015), The Multiple Streams Framework and the problem broker, European Journal of Political Research, 54: 450-465.
Lowery, D. (2013), Lobbying influence: meaning, measurement and missing, Interest Groups & Advocacy, 2 (1): 1-27.
Lutabingwa, J. and Gray, K.R. (1997), NGOs in sub-Saharan Africa: developing critical capacity for policy advocacy, International Journal on World Peace, XIV (3): 35-70.
Mahoney, C. (2007), Networking vs allying: the decision of interest groups to join coalitions in the US and the EU, Journal of European Public Policy, 14 (3): 366-383.
Mahoney, C. (2008), Brussels versus the Beltway: Advocacy in the United States and the European Union, Georgetown University Press: Washington, DC. 260pp.
Michalowitz, I. (2007), What determines influence? Assessing conditions for decisionmaking influence of interest groups in the EU, Journal of European Public Policy, 14 (1): 132-151.
NBCP, (2016), Importation and use of biological control agents in Tanzania, National Biological Control Programme
Nownes, A.J. and Newmark, A.J. (2016), It's all relative: perceptions of interest group influence, Interest Groups & Advocacy, 6 (1): 66-90.
Page, E.C. (1999), The insider/ outsider distinction: an empirical investigation, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 1 (2): 205-214.
Pawson, R. and Tilley, N. (1997), Realistic evaluation, Sage: London. 254pp.
Pedersen, H. H. (2013), Is measuring interest group influence a mission impossible? The case of interest group influence in the Danish parliament, Interest Groups & Advocacy, 2 (1): 27-47.
Poppelaars, C. (2007), Resource exchange in urban governance: on the means that matter, Urban Affairs Review, 43 (1): 3-27.
PublicPrivateDialogue, (2006), Charter of Good Practice in using Public Private Dialogue for Private Sector Development
Saurugger, S. (2008), Interest groups and democracy in the European Union, West European Politics, 31 (6): 274-1291.
Start, D. and Hovland, I. (2004), Tools for policy impact: a handbook for researchers, ODILondon
Temu, A.E. (2013), The political economy in which PSOs operate in Tanzania: implications for public private dialogue strategy, in BEST-AC: annual review and project completion report
Temu, A.E. and Due, J.M. (2000), The business environment in Tanzania after socialism:
challenges of reforming banks, parastatals, taxation and the civil service, Journal of Modern African Studies, 38 (4): 683-712.
TPSF (2016), Political Economy Analysis – 2016: How the political economy of Tanzania influences the business enabling environment, Tanzania Private Sector Foundation, Dar es Salaam. 24pp.
URT, (2010), National Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty II, Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs: Dar es Salaam
URT, (2011), Government Roadmap on the Improvement of the Investment Climate in Tanzania, Prime Minister's Office, Dar es Salaam
URT, (2012), Tanzania Open Government Partnership (OGP) Action Plan 2012-2013, URTDar es Salaam
URT, (2017), The Fertiliser (Amendments) Regulations 2017, Government PrinterDar es Salaam
Walker, J.L. (1991), Mobilizing interest groups in America, University of Michigan PressAnn Arbor, Mich
Woll, C. (2007), Leading the dance? power and political resources of business lobbyists, Journal of Public Policy, 27 (1): 57-78.
World Bank (2015), Tanzania Economic Update: Why should Tanzanians pay taxes? The unavoidable need to finance economic development, World Bank. Dar es Salaam.
World Bank (2018), Doing Business 2018: Reforming to create jobs, International Bank for Reconstruction and World Bank: Washington D.C. 313pp.
Yin, R.K. (2009), Case study research: designs and methods, 4th edition, Sage: London
